great to spend time with Amanda Bruce this afternoon.
Amanda is studying for ordination at Wycliffe Hall in Oxford and is considering doing the pioneer ministry training.
speaking with her brought up questions that come around again and again in discussions around emerging church / fresh expressions / pioneer ministry:
In what ways is a CofE-backed Fresh Expression 'Anglican'?
Does it matter? (it does to the bishop, and it should to the OPM if they were ordained by him and are happy to take a house, stipend and pension from the institution. I guess if we don't like it, we can always get a different job and do FE in our spare time...)
What about leadership succession? If you have an ordained pioneer minister kick something off and eventually they want to move on from the community, does another ordained person come in to lead it?
that would seem pretty odd to the community but what does the institution think?
Again, does it matter? (it does to the bishop).
(It's possible that an OPM could pioneer something interesting and then move on and their community could say to the bishop: 'we don't feel anglican, we don't really need another ordained person coming in to 'lead' or legitimise us, we'll do our own thing now thanks.')
Once you get thinking, this opens up massive questions about the motives of the institution in training OPMs and setting them free to do radical things.
Everyone has an agenda so it can't be that the institution really doesn't mind how these things evolve and whether or not they eventually reside in or outside the Anglican communion. Of course they mind. They want to see new, interesting life springing up from 'within' and refreshing the institution, not leaving it.
(therefore, Fresh Expressions in the CofE, must take certain things as read even if a fair bit of baggage is up for creative manipulation)
How do OPMs hold 'the institution' in tension with the need to be free to grow organically, follow the Spirit and develop with authenticity and integrity?
I don't know.
we're all making it up as we go along...